
Good morning!
It was nice while it lasted. Central Park intenSati was blissful (picture proof in case you doubt my word for any reason) and 12 of us took our field trip to the Ziegfeld to watch EPL. I kicked back, propped my leg, and melted into the movie just as I hoped and expected I would, making a concerted effort not to criticize the acting or script but just be pleased, moved and fed. It worked. I loved the experience of watching the movie and typing little quotes and nuggets into my iPhone. I liked watching how beautiful Julia looked in her little Saris and how breathtaking a site Javier Bali Bardem was. As I told one of my friends yesterday, my Hollywood crushes used to be of the fem' variety. Andrew McCarthy in "Pretty in Pink", for example, or Johnny Depp -- pretty boys, if you will -- but clearly taste shifts. The shot of the hunky, sexy, beasty, MAN Javier lounging with spectacles and a book in his hand (what was he reading? mystery) with what I think was a French jazz song in the background elicited a collective gasp from the sparse audience (at 12:30 the number of people in the theater could've fit in my living room) and I was a part of that wave. The shots of Julia going to town in Italy didn't disappoint, either. Think Napoleans, pappardelle, spaghetti, thin-crust pizza with bubbling cheese and deep red wine, mmmmmm...
I was reminded of the messages I took from reading the book (which, actually, was a planned "offering" as EG calls it. Viking partially subsidized her trip so she was writing with the intention to publish) such as the need for forgiveness of oneself and others to move on and heal wounds, the discovery and realization of God within, a need to recover your belief in love if you've been hurt and scarred from past relationships, the power of writing to help you understand yourself, the importance of meditation and the ultimate relief one can get by taking a giant (Does it have to be expensive? If you summed up how much she spent between the 3 countries it would probably be what I make in a year.) hiatus from your life in order to gain fresh, new perspectives and a clearer head.
So, when I woke up this morning and the buzz I felt yesterday seemed like it was absorbed by my patch-quilt overnight while I slept, I had to ask myself why. Then I had to ask the internet. What I found was a really interesting article on the online site Bitch Magazine (dot org) that criticizes "priv-lit" as embodied by Eat, Pray, Love and the self-help enlightenment movement spearheaded by Oprah Winfrey. I will be quoting from it a few times in italics from this source, the article entitled, "Eat, Pray, Spend. Priv-lit and the new enlightened American Dream" by Joshunda Sanders and Diana Barnes-Brown found here http://bitchmagazine.org/article/eat-pray-spend.
Eat, Pray, Love and its positioning as an Everywoman’s guide to whole, empowered living embody a literature of privilege and typify the genre’s destructive cacophony of insecurity, spending, and false wellness...
“Live your best life!” Oprah Winfrey intones on her show, on her website, and in her magazine, with exhausting tenacity. Eat kale*. Lose weight. Invest in timeless cashmere. Find the perfect little black dress. But though Oprahspeak pays regular lip service to empowerment, much of Winfrey’s advice actually moves women away from political, economic, and emotional agency by promoting materialism and dependency masked as empowerment, with evangelical zeal.
*What is it with kale?? Very popular these days and I've brought it into my apartment for two weeks straight now but have yet to cook it more than once. It's quite sharp to the taste buds. I think a part of me is curious how long kale lasts before it turns. It seems to have a very long shelf life. It looks at me from my refrigerator's second shelf as if to say, I am indestructible. Eat me...I think kale is the new spinach or anti-kryptonite, which would make those who eat it the new Pop Eye or Superman, Re-imagined. This helps explains its popularity, I'm sure.)
There was this moment in the film when EG makes her first two self-help book purchases in the aftermath of her painful decision to divorce her husband (the handsome, egotistical pastry chef very well-played by Billy Crudup). I think one was called From Crappy to Happy. It was a moment that of course relates to the millions of women (myself very much included) who have picked up self-help, personal, spiritual growth resources in the hopes of finding answers to one's problems, insights that perhaps we'd glean over time but perhaps unconsciously would like to acquire by doing less work and instead witnessing someone else's painful journey of soul searching and healing. Growth by osmosis. Yet, to refer back to this Bitch Mag article,
Self-improvement culture in general has the contradictory effect of undermining self-assurance by suggesting that all of us are in need of constant, effortful (and often expensive) improvement. There is the danger of over-investing in this literature not only financially, but also psychologically.
Fascinating. This is how I felt about the culture of therapy and treatment of "mental illness" and addiction. When I was first being treated for "depression" and an "eating disorder" in college by a nutritionist, doctor and therapist, I thought the approach and discourse of diagnostic criteria was absolutely appalling and falsely lead me to believe I was very, very "sick" and needed the kind of help reserved for people with advanced psychosis. The self-help books were actually a relief for me and an empowered space, comparatively, but now that years have gone by, I can even see how the many books I've embraced may have been hindering my growth. Namely, by the distancing of myself from my own opinions, thoughts and insights, and a reliance upon others as a source or authority for truth as well as reinforcing a belief that I am perpetually in need of help.
What if I actually woke up one Sunday morning in my apartment and instead of popping open my laptop with the intention to FIX myself vis a vis my writing -- and yes, that is always there in the back of mind, this notion of uncovering some more truth or doing a good job of healing or expressing, something that will help me grow because I need to grow, some writing that will help me improve because I need to improve in wisdom and intelligence -- what if, I only woke up on Sunday morning, or any morning, to just greet the world.
What if my belief, my underlying belief, was that I am whole now. That I am, after all these years and all this work, pretty much fine. Perfect? No. Who is. That my growth can happen naturally over time and without fierce intentions.
I think I'd enjoy myself more. I think I'd enjoy my breakfast coffee and oat bran a lot more.
Balance was mentioned a few times in the film yesterday, once even defined as (and I know bc I typed it onto my iPhone), "balance is not letting anybody love you less than you love yourself" which is beautiful, isn't it? Yes, but I'm digressing and it doesn't really have to do w/ what I'm talking about right now :)
Balance with respect to the kinds of self help resources I seek and self analysis I do, balance between saying, Yes, I need to analyze this and No, there's really nothing to say or think about, in fact, its probably best I don't do either but just go about my life...
If more women become willing to put aside their fears, open their eyes to cost-free or inexpensive paths to wellness, and position themselves as essentially worthy instead of deeply flawed, priv-lit could soon migrate to a well-deserved new home: the fiction section. And once that happens, we might just succeed in showing that for every wealthy and insecure woman who can pony up to reach great heights of self and spending, there are thousands more whose lives are comparatively uncharmed, who are happier working with creative and healthy alternatives instead of spending on what they’re terrorized into wanting, and whose stories will, someday, be valued for the strength they communicate, not the fantasies they sell.
The fiction section. Fantasies. I don't know. That's really harsh. Certainly the movie version of EPL does feel like it can be a fantasy but the book did not have that same effect on me at all. It felt honest and it felt probably at the time. That self discovery and the necessary healing can bring about a transformation that results in greater love and happiness in one's life. That's all I am really seeking, I think, and I do not believe I have to run to three countries to achieve this, much as I would like to test my Italian (studie tres semestre in l'scuola) and spend a month in Bali (no Javier Bardemlike guy is necessary). I have no desire to go to India right now. I really just want another cup of coffee and to go meet my friends today.
Have a beautiful Sunday!!!!
xo Lindsay